Too Much of a Good Thing: How to Deal with a Concentrated Position

Smiling woman and man in outdoor jackets stand together in a sunlit forest.

Key Takeaways

  • A concentrated stock position often comes with a huge, unrealized gain, a significant potential tax bill, and a portfolio that’s dangerously dependent on one company’s fortunes.
  • Options overlay strategies, such as protective puts and cashless collars, can reduce the risk of a concentrated position without triggering a full sale.
  • Separately managed accounts with tax-loss harvesting, exchange funds, and charitable strategies offer other ways to diversify while managing the tax consequences.
  • Sometimes the best answer is simply to sell some of the stock and take the tax hit. Don’t let the tax tail wag the investment dog.

I’ve lost count of how many times a client has sat across from me, looked at a single line on their statement, and said some version of the same thing: “I know I shouldn’t have this much in one stock. But I just can’t bring myself to sell.”

Maybe it’s the founder’s stock they’ve held since the IPO. Maybe it’s shares inherited from a parent, cost basis frozen somewhere back in the Reagan administration. Maybe it’s simply a security that’s done so well for so long that selling feels like betting against a winning horse. Whatever the story, it often comes with a huge, unrealized gain, a tax bill that makes your stomach turn, and a portfolio that’s dangerously dependent on one company’s fortunes.

This is a common and emotionally loaded conversation that we have regularly at Curi Capital. There’s no single right answer, but there are tools and options, and part of our job is walking clients through them so their decision is driven by strategy rather than fear.

Option 1 | Keep the Stock, Change the Risk

One way to reduce the risk of a concentrated position without triggering a full sale is through options overlay strategies.

Think of it less like selling the house and more like renovating it while you still live there. A protective put creates a floor under the stock, limiting how much you can lose if the price drops. A cashless collar pairs that downside protection with a sale of upside calls, essentially trading away some blue-sky potential in exchange for a cushion. These strategies can also generate income while allowing you to continue owning the shares, collecting dividends, and retaining voting rights. You still own the stock, but the ride gets a little less white-knuckle.

Option 2 | Separately Managed Accounts with Tax-Loss Harvesting

Another approach is to move a concentrated position into a separately managed account designed to help reshape the risk profile while also improving tax efficiency. These strategies can incorporate long-only or long/short approaches and use disciplined tax-loss harvesting to offset gains elsewhere in the portfolio over time. For the right client, this can be a thoughtful way to reduce concentration risk while managing the tax consequences more strategically.

Option 3 | Exchange Funds

We use exchange funds more sparingly than other strategies, largely because they come with trade-offs such as long lock-up periods, less flexibility, and eligibility requirements that not every client meets. But for the right situation, pooling a concentrated stock into a diversified basket alongside other investors’ concentrated positions can be a genuinely effective solution. You walk in with one stock and, years later, walk out with a diversified portfolio. It’s a tool worth having in the kit, even if it’s not our first call.

Option 4 | Give Some of It Away, Thoughtfully

Not every solution is about keeping the money. Sometimes the simplest approach is also one of the most effective: donating appreciated stock directly to a qualified charity. By giving the shares instead of selling them first, clients can generally avoid paying capital gains tax on the donated stock while potentially receiving a charitable deduction for its fair market value.

If the desire is to generate a larger tax benefit, a donor-advised fund (DAF) lets a client contribute appreciated stock, take an immediate tax deduction, and then direct grants to causes they care about over time. This avoids having to write a check from cash or triggering capital gains on the shares donated.

For clients thinking bigger, a charitable remainder trust can convert a concentrated position into a stream of income for life, with the remainder eventually going to charity. This is a way to diversify, generate cash flow, and support a mission all in one structure. For families with real philanthropic ambitions, we sometimes talk about establishing a family foundation, which turns a stock position into a multigenerational vehicle for both giving and family governance.

And Sometimes — Just Sell It

Sometimes, the best answer is simply to sell some of the stock and take the tax hit. I understand the instinct of avoiding it. Nobody enjoys writing a check to the IRS. But I’ve also watched families let a tax bill dictate a portfolio strategy that runs counter to the choice they’d make with a clear head. Don’t let the tax tail wag the investment dog.

We believe that diversification isn’t a nice-to-have; it’s a vital part of a well-structured financial plan. A single stock, no matter how wonderful the company, can carry risks that no amount of clever structuring can fully engineer away. This strategy might not be as esoteric or unique as the options above. However, with sophisticated, detailed tax planning, we can thoughtfully help clients reduce their concentration risk.

There’s no universal playbook here. The right mix of options overlays, separately managed accounts, exchange funds, charitable strategies, and old-fashioned selling depends on your goals, your tax situation, and, at the end of the day, your ability to sleep soundly with the decisions you’ve made. That’s exactly the conversation that the Curi Capital team is here to have with our clients.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can you reduce the risk of a concentrated stock position without selling?

One way is through options overlay strategies. A protective put creates a floor under the stock, limiting how much you can lose if the price drops. A cashless collar pairs that downside protection with a sale of upside calls, trading away some upside potential in exchange for a cushion. These strategies can also generate income while allowing you to continue owning the shares, collecting dividends, and retaining voting rights.

What is an exchange fund?

An exchange fund pools a concentrated stock into a diversified basket alongside other investors’ concentrated positions. You walk in with one stock and, years later, walk out with a diversified portfolio. Exchange funds come with trade-offs, such as long lock-up periods, less flexibility, and eligibility requirements that not every client meets.

Can donating appreciated stock help with a concentrated position?

Yes. By donating appreciated shares directly to a qualified charity instead of selling them first, you can generally avoid paying capital gains tax on the donated stock while potentially receiving a charitable deduction for its fair market value. A donor-advised fund (DAF) lets you contribute appreciated stock, take an immediate tax deduction, and direct grants over time. A charitable remainder trust can convert a concentrated position into a stream of income for life, with the remainder eventually going to charity.

Should you just sell a concentrated stock position?

Sometimes, the best answer is simply to sell some of the stock and take the tax hit. A single stock, no matter how wonderful the company, can carry risks that no amount of clever structuring can fully engineer away. The right mix of strategies depends on your goals, your tax situation, and your ability to sleep soundly with the decisions you’ve made.

Disclaimers

The opinions and analyses expressed in this presentation are based on Curi Capital LLC’s (“Curi Capital”) research and professional experience and are expressed as of the date of this presentation. Certain information expressed represents an assessment at a specific point in time and is not intended to be a forecast or guarantee of future performance, nor is it intended to speak to any future time periods. Curi Capital makes no warranty or representation, express or implied, nor does Curi Capital accept any liability, with respect to the information and data set forth herein, and Curi Capital specifically disclaims any duty to update any of the information and data contained in this presentation. The information and data in this presentation does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, investment, or other professional advice.

The content contained herein was generated by Curi Capital with the assistance of an AI-based system to augment the effort.

Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards, Inc. owns the certification marks CFP®, CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ and federally registered CFP (with flame design) in the U.S., which it awards to individuals who successfully complete CFP Board’s initial and ongoing certification requirements. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.